- Published on
AI Slop: Building Trust in Faculty Governance
- Name
- Sam Schwartz
- Position
- Founder
- Organization
- The University Matters
Prompt
What are concrete, actionable, forward looking ways for faculty senates to increase trust among their shared governance partners (e.g., admin and the governing board) and external stakeholders (e.g., community leaders, Republican and Democratic politicians, the general public, etc.)?
Response
From ChatGPT 5
Great question. Faculty senates are often framed as the “voice of the faculty,” but their reputation (and therefore trust) varies a lot depending on whether they’re seen as obstructionist, irrelevant, or constructive. Below is a forward-looking, concrete set of actions faculty senates can take to build trust with both internal (administration, boards) and external stakeholders (public, political, community).
1. With Administration & Governing Boards
Goal: Shift perception from adversarial to collaborative partner.
- Joint Priority-Setting Retreats: Co-host annual retreats with administration and board reps to set shared academic and financial priorities, so senates are part of framing—not just reacting.
- Policy Impact Memos: For each resolution passed, accompany it with a one-page “impact memo” that explains practical implications for students, budget, and public trust—making faculty input legible to non-faculty.
- Standing Senate Delegation to Board Meetings: Have a senate exec (chair or delegate) provide a concise, constructive “state of the faculty” report at every board meeting—3 minutes max, focused on progress and solutions.
- Rapid-Response Consultation Groups: Pre-identify faculty across disciplines who can be tapped for quick, evidence-based advice on hot issues (budget, academic freedom, workforce needs). This shows responsiveness and value.
- Shared Metrics Dashboard: Co-develop with admin a dashboard of metrics (student success, program vitality, faculty workload, financial sustainability) that’s public and updated annually. Demonstrates transparency.
2. With Community Leaders
Goal: Show faculty as partners in regional prosperity, not just inward-looking academics.
- Community Research Showcases: Organize twice-yearly showcases where faculty present applied research, student projects, and service partnerships to business and civic leaders.
- Faculty-in-Residence Programs: Place faculty (especially from fields like education, business, engineering, health) in short-term residencies at local nonprofits, K-12 schools, and industry groups.
- Local Needs Roundtables: Senate sponsors quarterly roundtables with chambers of commerce, workforce boards, and nonprofits to align university programs with community needs.
- Open Senate Forums: Host one senate meeting per semester in a community venue (library, high school, town hall), livestream it, and allow public comment. Builds visibility and accountability.
3. With Politicians (Both Parties)
Goal: Reduce perception of partisanship, highlight broad value.
- Bipartisan Policy Briefs: Issue short, plain-language briefs on topics like workforce training, student debt, rural access, healthcare needs. Always send to both parties.
- Capitol Days Led by Senate: Organize delegations of faculty + students to state legislatures. Present success stories (first-gen student outcomes, regional economic impact).
- Faculty Advisory Councils: Offer to staff legislative committees with nonpartisan, evidence-based faculty expertise.
- Rotating Issue Spotlights: Each semester, senate highlights one cross-cutting issue (e.g., rural teacher shortage, cybersecurity workforce, opioid crisis) and convenes a bipartisan discussion with legislators.
4. With the General Public
Goal: Make faculty visible as stewards of public trust and student success.
- Plain-Language Annual Report: Senate publishes a short, infographic-style report each year: what faculty did to improve teaching, support students, cut costs, contribute to community.
- Faculty Op-Ed Corps: Senate maintains a roster of faculty ready to publish op-eds or provide commentary to local press on timely issues.
- Public Service Commitments: Track and highlight hours faculty contribute to community service, public schools, nonprofits, and make this visible on the senate’s website.
- Student Voices in Senate: Make one senate seat (non-voting) for a student rep, and showcase student testimony in senate newsletters. Signals alignment with student experience.
- Social Media Transparency: Senate posts meeting highlights, decisions, and community impacts on accessible channels—avoiding jargon.
5. Cultural/Behavioral Shifts
- “Solutions, not just objections.” Train senators to frame critiques with a constructive alternative.
- Time Discipline. Adopt rules for shorter, more focused meetings with clear outputs—signals seriousness.
- Proactive Storytelling. Regularly communicate wins (e.g., curriculum improvements, faculty-student projects) rather than only reacting to crises.
- Self-Reform. Periodically audit the senate itself (diversity of membership, transparency of process) and publish reforms publicly.
✅ The key thread across all of this: faculty senates gain trust when they stop being seen as inward-facing debating societies and become outward-facing, solution-oriented, transparent partners.
Would you like me to make this into a one-page “Faculty Senate Trust Playbook” (like a handout you could actually give to senate leaders), or would you prefer a longer, multi-section white paper that digs deeper into each stakeholder group?

Sam Schwartz
Sam is the founder of UMatters.org. He is an assistant professor of computer science at the University of Wisconsin - Eau Claire. Views are his own.